If you want a natural lash, don't bother with this mascara. As the name claims, this is perfect for a smokey, night eye. Where this mascara doesn't clump, it does leave lashes thick and full, as well as long and curled. I always use a lash curler with this mascara to give an even fuller effect, but it is definitely not necessary. While this mascara doesn't have a drugstore price-tag, the quality has convinced me to repurchase this mascara again and again. This comes in many colors, including the more interesting blue, green, and purple, but I am tried and true to my rich black.
$23 at Sephora or Makeup Forever stores and online
texture 8 (works well new or slightly dried out)
hold 7 (never had a problem, wears around 12 hours without flaking)
application 7 (brush isn't too large, can still easily get bottom lashes)
buildability 8 (will not clump until the third coat; trust me, you don't need a third coat)
overall 8
total 38/50 For its purpose, I really love this mascara. I have given it as gifts and heard nothing but good things from others as well.